Independence Testing

Finding trends in data is pretty hard. Independence testing is a fundamental tool that helps us find trends in data and make further decisions based on these results. This testing is desirable to answer many question such as: does brain connectivity effect creativity? Does gene expression effect cancer? Does something effect something else?

If you are interested in questions of this mold, this module of the package is for you! All our tests can be found in hyppo.independence, and will be elaborated in detail below. But before that, let's look at the mathematical formulations:

Consider random variables \(X\) and \(Y\) with distributions \(F_X\) and \(F_Y\) respectively, and joint distribution is \(F_{XY} = F_{Y|X} F_X\). When performing independence testing, we are seeing whether or not \(F_{Y|X} = F_Y\). That is, we are testing

\[\begin{split}H_0 &: F_{XY} = F_X F_Y \\ H_A &: F_{XY} \neq F_X F_Y\end{split}\]

Like all the other tests within hyppo, each method has a statistic and test method. The test method is the one that returns the test statistic and p-values, among other outputs, and is the one that is used most often in the examples, tutorials, etc. The p-value returned is calculated using a permutation test using hyppo.tools.perm_test unless otherwise specified.

Specifics about how the test statistics are calculated for each in hyppo.independence can be found the docstring of the respective test. Here, we overview subsets of the types of independence tests we offer in hyppo, and special parameters unique to those tests.

Now, let's look at unique properties of some of the tests in hyppo.independence:

Pearson's Correlation Multivariate Variants

Cannonical correlation (CCA) and Rank value (RV) are multivariate analogues of Pearson's correlation. More details can be found in hyppo.independence.CCA and hyppo.independence.RV. The following applies to both:

Note

Pros

• Very fast

• Similar to tests found in scientific literature

Cons

• Not accurate when compared to other tests in most situations

• Makes dangerous variance assumptions about the data, among others (similar assumptions to Pearson's correlation)

Neither of these test are distance based, and so do not have a compute_distance parameter. Otherwise, these tests runs like any other test.

Distance (and Kernel) Based Tests

A number of tests within hyppo.independence use the concept of inter-sample distance, or kernel similarity, to generate powerful indpendence tests.

Heller Heller Gorfine (HHG) is a powerful multivariate independence test that compares intersample distance, and computes a Pearson statistic. More details can be found in hyppo.independence.HHG.

Note

Pros

• Very accurate in certain settings

Cons

• Very slow (computationally complex)

• Test statistic not very interpretable, not between (-1, 1)

This test runs like any other test.

---

Distance Correlation (Dcorr) is a powerful multivariate independence test based on energy distance. Hilbert Schmidt Independence Criterion (Hsic) is a kernel-based analogue to Dcorr that uses the a Gaussian median kernel by default [1]. More details can be found in hyppo.independence.Dcorr and hyppo.independence.Hsic. The following applies to both:

Note

Pros

• Accurate, powerful independence test for multivariate and nonlinear data

• Has enticing empiral properties (foundation of some of the other tests in the package)

• Has fast implementations (fastest test in the package)

Cons

• Slightly less accurate as the above tests

For Hsic, kernels are used instead of distances with the compute_kernel parameter. Any addition, if the bias variant of the test statistic is required, then the bias parameter can be set to True. In general, we do not recommend doing this. Otherwise, these tests runs like any other test. Since Dcorr and Hsic are implemented similarly, let's look at Dcorr.

import timeit

import numpy as np

setup_code = """
from hyppo.independence import Dcorr
from hyppo.tools import w_shaped
x1, y1 = w_shaped(n=100, p=3, noise=True)
x2, y2 = w_shaped(n=100, p=1, noise=True)
"""

t_perm = timeit.Timer(stmt="Dcorr().test(x1, y1, auto=False)", setup=setup_code)
t_chisq = timeit.Timer(stmt="Dcorr().test(x1, y1, auto=True)", setup=setup_code)
t_fast_perm = timeit.Timer(stmt="Dcorr().test(x2, y2, auto=True)", setup=setup_code)
t_fast_chisq = timeit.Timer(stmt="Dcorr().test(x2, y2, auto=True)", setup=setup_code)

perm_time = np.array(t_perm.timeit(number=1))  # permutation Dcorr
chisq_time = np.array(t_chisq.timeit(number=1000)) / 1000  # fast Dcorr
fast_perm_time = np.array(t_fast_perm.timeit(number=1))  # permutation Dcorr
fast_chisq_time = np.array(t_fast_chisq.timeit(number=1000)) / 1000  # fast Dcorr

print(u"Permutation time: {0:.3g}s".format(perm_time))
print(u"Fast time (chi-square): {0:.3g}s".format(chisq_time))
print(u"Permutation time (fast statistic): {0:.3g}s".format(fast_perm_time))
print(u"Fast time (fast statistic chi-square): {0:.3g}s".format(fast_chisq_time))

Out:

Permutation time: 73.2s
Fast time (chi-square): 0.0148s
Permutation time (fast statistic): 0.00244s
Fast time (fast statistic chi-square): 0.00182s

Look at the time increases when using the fast test! The fast test approximates the null distribution as a chi-squared random variable, and so is far faster than the permutation method. To call it, simply set auto to True, which is the default, and if your data has a sample size greater than 20, then the test will run. In the case where the data is 1 dimensional and Euclidean, an even faster version is run.

---

Multiscale graph correlation (MGC) is a powerful independence test the uses the power of Dcorr and k-nearest neighbors to create an efficient and powerful independence test. More details can be found in hyppo.independence.MGC.

Note

We recently added the majority of the source code of this algorithm to scipy.stats.multiscale_graphcorr. This class serves as a wrapper for that implementation.

Note

Pros

• Highly accurate, powerful independence test for multivariate and nonlinear data

• Gives information about geometric nature of the dependency

Cons

• Slightly slower than similar tests in this section

MGC has some specific differences outlined below, but creating the instance of the class was demonstrated in the General Workflow in the Overview.

from hyppo.independence import MGC
from hyppo.tools import w_shaped

# 100 samples, 1D x and 1D y, noise
x, y = w_shaped(n=100, p=1, noise=True)

# get the MGC map and optimal scale (only need the statistic)
_, _, mgc_dict = MGC().test(x, y, reps=0)

A unique property of MGC is a MGC map, which is a (n, n) map (or (n, k) where k is less than n if there are repeated values). This shows you the test statistics at all these different "scales". The optimal scale is an ordered pair that indicates nearest neighbors where the test statistic is maximized and is marked by a red "X". This optimal scale is the location of the test statistic. The heat map gives insights into the nature of the dependency between x and y. Otherwise, this test runs like any other test. We can plot it below:

import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
import matplotlib.ticker as ticker
import seaborn as sns

# make plots look pretty
sns.set(color_codes=True, style="white", context="talk", font_scale=1)

mgc_map = mgc_dict["mgc_map"]
opt_scale = mgc_dict["opt_scale"]  # i.e. maximum smoothed test statistic
print("Optimal Scale:", opt_scale)

# create figure
fig, (ax, cax) = plt.subplots(
    ncols=2, figsize=(9, 8.5), gridspec_kw={"width_ratios": [1, 0.05]}
)

# draw heatmap and colorbar
ax = sns.heatmap(mgc_map, cmap="YlGnBu", ax=ax, cbar=False)
fig.colorbar(ax.get_children()[0], cax=cax, orientation="vertical")
ax.invert_yaxis()

# optimal scale
ax.scatter(opt_scale[1], opt_scale[0], marker="X", s=200, color="red")

# make plots look nice
ax.set_title("MGC Map")
ax.xaxis.set_major_locator(ticker.MultipleLocator(10))
ax.xaxis.set_major_formatter(ticker.ScalarFormatter())
ax.yaxis.set_major_locator(ticker.MultipleLocator(10))
ax.yaxis.set_major_formatter(ticker.ScalarFormatter())
ax.set_xlabel("Neighbors for x")
ax.set_ylabel("Neighbors for y")
ax.set_xticks([0, 50, 100])
ax.set_yticks([0, 50, 100])
ax.xaxis.set_tick_params()
ax.yaxis.set_tick_params()
cax.xaxis.set_tick_params()
cax.yaxis.set_tick_params()
plt.show()

Out:

/opt/buildhome/python3.7/lib/python3.7/site-packages/seaborn/cm.py:1582: UserWarning: Trying to register the cmap 'rocket' which already exists.
  mpl_cm.register_cmap(_name, _cmap)
/opt/buildhome/python3.7/lib/python3.7/site-packages/seaborn/cm.py:1583: UserWarning: Trying to register the cmap 'rocket_r' which already exists.
  mpl_cm.register_cmap(_name + "_r", _cmap_r)
/opt/buildhome/python3.7/lib/python3.7/site-packages/seaborn/cm.py:1582: UserWarning: Trying to register the cmap 'mako' which already exists.
  mpl_cm.register_cmap(_name, _cmap)
/opt/buildhome/python3.7/lib/python3.7/site-packages/seaborn/cm.py:1583: UserWarning: Trying to register the cmap 'mako_r' which already exists.
  mpl_cm.register_cmap(_name + "_r", _cmap_r)
/opt/buildhome/python3.7/lib/python3.7/site-packages/seaborn/cm.py:1582: UserWarning: Trying to register the cmap 'icefire' which already exists.
  mpl_cm.register_cmap(_name, _cmap)
/opt/buildhome/python3.7/lib/python3.7/site-packages/seaborn/cm.py:1583: UserWarning: Trying to register the cmap 'icefire_r' which already exists.
  mpl_cm.register_cmap(_name + "_r", _cmap_r)
/opt/buildhome/python3.7/lib/python3.7/site-packages/seaborn/cm.py:1582: UserWarning: Trying to register the cmap 'vlag' which already exists.
  mpl_cm.register_cmap(_name, _cmap)
/opt/buildhome/python3.7/lib/python3.7/site-packages/seaborn/cm.py:1583: UserWarning: Trying to register the cmap 'vlag_r' which already exists.
  mpl_cm.register_cmap(_name + "_r", _cmap_r)
/opt/buildhome/python3.7/lib/python3.7/site-packages/seaborn/cm.py:1582: UserWarning: Trying to register the cmap 'flare' which already exists.
  mpl_cm.register_cmap(_name, _cmap)
/opt/buildhome/python3.7/lib/python3.7/site-packages/seaborn/cm.py:1583: UserWarning: Trying to register the cmap 'flare_r' which already exists.
  mpl_cm.register_cmap(_name + "_r", _cmap_r)
/opt/buildhome/python3.7/lib/python3.7/site-packages/seaborn/cm.py:1582: UserWarning: Trying to register the cmap 'crest' which already exists.
  mpl_cm.register_cmap(_name, _cmap)
/opt/buildhome/python3.7/lib/python3.7/site-packages/seaborn/cm.py:1583: UserWarning: Trying to register the cmap 'crest_r' which already exists.
  mpl_cm.register_cmap(_name + "_r", _cmap_r)
Optimal Scale: [33, 100]

For linear data, we would expect the optimal scale to be at the maximum nearest neighbor pair. Since we consider nonlinear data, this is not the case.

Random Forest Based Tests

Random-forest based tests exploit the theoretical properties of decision tree based classifiers to create highly accurate tests (especially in cases of high dimensional data sets).

Kernel mean embedding random forest (KMERF) is one such test, which uses similarity matrices as a result of random forest to generate a test statistic and p-value. More details can be found in hyppo.independence.KMERF.

Note

Pros

• Highly accurate, powerful independence test for multivariate and nonlinear data

• Gives information about releative dimension (or feature) importance

Cons

• Very slow (requires training a random forest for each permutation)

Unlike other tests, there is no compute_distance parameter. Instead, the number of trees can be set explicityly, and the type of classifier can be set ("classifier" in the case where the return value \(y\) is categorical, and "regressor" when that is not the case). Check out sklearn.ensemble.RandomForestClassifier and sklearn.ensemble.RandomForestRegressor for additional parameters to change. Otherwise, this test runs like any other test.

from hyppo.independence import KMERF
from hyppo.tools import cubic

# 100 samples, 5D sim
x, y = cubic(n=100, p=5)

# get the feature importances (only need the statistic)
_, _, kmerf_dict = KMERF(ntrees=5000).test(x, y, reps=0)

Because this test is random-forest based, we can get feature importances. This gives us relative importances value of dimension (i.e. feature). KMERF returns a normalized version of this parameter, and we can plot these importances:

importances = kmerf_dict["feat_importance"]
dims = range(1, 6)  # range of dimensions of simulation


import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
import seaborn as sns

# make plots look pretty
sns.set(color_codes=True, style="white", context="talk", font_scale=1)

# plot the feature importances
plt.figure(figsize=(9, 6.5))
plt.plot(dims, importances)
plt.xlim([1, 5])
plt.xticks([1, 2, 3, 4, 5])
plt.xlabel("Dimensions")
plt.ylim([0, 1])
plt.yticks([])
plt.ylabel("Normalized Feature Importance")
plt.title("Feature Importances")
plt.show()

We see that feature importances decreases as dimension increases. This is true for most of the simulations in hyppo.tools.

Maximal Margin Correlation

Maximial Margin Correlation takes the independence tests in hyppo.independence, and compute the maximal correlation of pairwise comparisons between each dimension of x and y. More details can be found in hyppo.independence.MaxMargin.

Note

Pros

• As powerful as some of the tests within this module

• Minimal decrease in testing power as dimension increases

Cons

• Adds computational complexity, so can be slow

These tests have an indep_test parameter corresponding to the desired independence test to be run. All the parameters from the above tests can also be modified, and see the relevant section of reference documentation in hyppo.independence for more information. These tests runs like any other test.